This morning I attended a forum:
"FROM PROTEST TO POLICY: POLICING IN COMMUNITIES OF COLOR" with the
Reverend Al Sharpton. Although I find that I cannot readily agree that the response of rioting as a reaction to the Michael Brown incident in Ferguson was useless, I do agree with Sharpton that any rage that is expressed as a reaction to injustice should be channeled in a strategic way if at all possible. The issue of who is entitled to rage or whose "strategic" rage gets responded to in this country is another story.
Black men are made to feel like monstruous threats whether they assert themselves or not. In affect they are seen as threats because they exist. I am not a Black man but I am married to one and I have heard him recount stories of being approached, pulled over and harassed by cops. I cannot say for sure whether or not It would easy for me to respond to these situations in a calm manner. My husband has been a witness to my temper in way I'm pretty certain no one else has. It's not pretty.
I have a deluded sense of entitlement when it comes to what I feel I can get away with doing in public and do not take very kindly to being held to rules I consider petty which restrict that deluded sense of entitlement. I get that from my mom, a notorious rebel and rule breaker in her family. I still walk between train cars on the MTA. Never been pulled aside by cops for it. Never been pulled aside or handled by cops for anything for that matter. Do you understand?
However, as men of color, when you are treated from very young as a group whose potential contribution to society is limited to low paying undervalued positions, and as someone who is not intelligent enough to do better than drug dealer or gang banger, it is simply a matter of time before the pot will boil over, simply a matter of a series of inevitable systematical events both external and internal that lead to the possibility of looting and rioting and store windows being shattered, fires being started. It starts with slavery and continues to this day.
With regard to strategic rage, I think that there needs to be more work around undoing the violence that incites the rage in the first place before we can start talking about strategic rage on the part of people of color. This may be a reactionary comment because I have not yet learned how to sufficiently channel or diffuse my own rage and anger about a range of issues but I feel like asking Black and Brown men to be strategic about their rage is just.... to put it nicely, an uninformed request
The law of cause and effect with regard to the ways in which policy brutality is met with equal or surpassed violence from those who are oppressed by it seem to be in perfect order as far as I'm concerned. To apply this example globally, well...okay I won't go there now, but let's just say that when you attack innocent and unarmed people and or nations mercilessly, you got an ass whoopin coming to you that no strategy can curtail. These are the circumstances that have been created. These are the conditions we live in. People of color don't all have the luxury of benefiting from systemic racism and it's violence and then turning around and saying that those who are oppressed and brutalized by it need to back the fuck down and take it "strategically." So shit will hit the fan as it should and as is subject to by the laws of cause and effect.
I was watching Ken Burn's "The Roosevelts" last night and just found myself rapt with fascination over the documentation of the Great Depression and the ways in which Roosevelt unlike any other American President before him was able to connect with Americans, gain their trust and implement some programs and policy that seemed to really make a difference in the lives of Americans whose lives were devastated by the Depression. Now it's not to say that all the Americans who could identify as White or "non-black" were in total harmony with one another but they did benefit for the most part from these policy and program implementations, and when a majority of people who find are able to be relieved from the ravages of destitute poverty there is a sense of unity and camaraderie that is uplifting and energetic, inspiring and just plain incredible to witness. The
NRA parade was a perfect example of that.
And then there was the footage of the Black families and narratives of their written pleas to President Roosevelt for help and the torrent of resistance he was met with in his cabinet when trying to implement anti lynching laws into the Constitution. And my heart just dropped. Because they were Americans. But they were not treated as Americans. And it made me feel inexplicably helpless. Because this is still happening now. Red lining, racial profiling, lynching...
Rage has it's place.